-
- Downloads
refactor: modularize site components (#1058)
Hi everyone, this is a large refactoring PR that looks to **modularize site components** following the discussion in #959. At the top-level, it: - moves icons, the sidebar, header (navbar, search, aux links), footer, and mermaid components of the `default` layout into their own `_includes` - creates a new `minimal` layout that does not render the header or sidebar as a proof-of-concept for the composability of components - documents all existing and new layouts (including vendor code) in the "Customization" section An important goal of this PR is for it to be **just code motion and flexibility**: there should be **zero impact** on the average end user that only consumes the `default` theme. The next few sections go in-depth on each of the listed changes. ### new components The `default` layout contains a "list" of all relevant components. Importantly, some of these components have sub-components: - the header is split into the search bar, custom code, and aux links - the icons include imports different icon components, some of which are conditionally imported by feature guards There are also candidates for future splits and joins: - the sidebar could be split into navigation, collections, external link, and header/footer code - the "search footer" could be joined with other search code, which would make it easier to "include search" in one go; *however, this is a markup change* - @kevinlin1 has pointed out that there is some leakage between the sidebar (which computes parents/grandparents) and the breadcrumbs (which needs them to render). He's graciously added a bandaid fix to `minimal` (which does not render the sidebar). However, in the long term, we should either: - calculate this in a parent and pass the information to both components - change how this works entirely (which may happen with multi-level navigation) @pdmosses has done a great job outlining this and more in his [Modular Layouts test site](https://pdmosses.github.io/modular-layouts/docs/main/). ### minimal layout Based on @kevinlin1's use-case in just-the-class (see: his [Winter 2023 CSE 373 site](https://courses.cs.washington.edu/courses/cse373/23wi/)), we've created a first-class `minimal` layout that does not render the sidebar or header. In a [comment](https://github.com/just-the-docs/just-the-docs/pull/1058#discussion_r1057015039), Kevin has indicated that we can re-add the search bar in the minimal layout; however, it seems like this would be a code change. I think we should punt this to a future issue/PR. @pdmosses has also discussed the confusion of `minimal` as a layout and its meaning in inheritance. I've added a note in documentation to clarify the (lack of) inheritance relationship. ### documentation I've written documentation in the "Customization" page / [Custom layouts and includes](https://deploy-preview-1058--just-the-docs.netlify.app/docs/customization/#custom-layouts-and-includes) section explaining: - generally, that we use includes/layouts (and pointing to docs) - the `default` layout and its constituent components (with a warning about name collisions) - creating alternative layouts with `minimal` as an example - the inheritance chain of layouts and the vendor layouts that we consume I've also created (and linked to) a [minimal layout test](https://deploy-preview-1058--just-the-docs.netlify.app/docs/minimal-test/) that is currently a copy of the markdown kitchen sink but with the minimal layout. I think there's room to improve this in the future. ### future work I think there's a lot we can do. Let me break this into various sections. Potential follow-ups before `v0.4.0`: - re-including search in `minimal` (anticipating a minor code change) - fixing the leakage of parent/grandparent information between the sidebar and breadcrumbs (anticipating no end-user code change, but good to evaluate separately and discuss) - heavily document this in the migration guide (#1059) and in our RC4 release docs - improve semantic markup for components (ex `main`, `nav`) Related work in later minor versions: - split up components into smaller components - allow users to easily customize new layouts using frontmatter (see @kevinlin1's [comment in #959](https://github.com/just-the-docs/just-the-docs/issues/959#issuecomment-1249755249)) Related work for `v1.0` (i.e. a major breaking change): - rename and better categorize existing includes - standardizing the "custom" includes - moving other components to the `components/` folder (ex `head`, `nav`) - potentially: less confusing naming for various components - potentially separate the search and header as components, so that they are completely independent Tangentially related work: - more flexible grid (see @JPrevost's [comment in this PR thread](https://github.com/just-the-docs/just-the-docs/pull/1058#issuecomment-1363314610)) - a formal [feature model](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feature_model) of JTD, documenting feature dependence (see @pdmosses's [comment in this PR thread](https://github.com/just-the-docs/just-the-docs/pull/1058#issuecomment-1365414023)) - better annotate new features (motivated by writing these docs) - we should add "New" to new features :) - we should note when a feature was introduced (I think this is a core part of most software documentation) - we should annotate things that are "Advanced" in so far as the average Just the Docs user will not use them / they require significant Jekyll knowledge --- Closes #959.
Showing
- _includes/components/aux_nav.html 15 additions, 0 deletions_includes/components/aux_nav.html
- _includes/components/breadcrumbs.html 15 additions, 0 deletions_includes/components/breadcrumbs.html
- _includes/components/children_nav.html 9 additions, 0 deletions_includes/components/children_nav.html
- _includes/components/footer.html 34 additions, 0 deletions_includes/components/footer.html
- _includes/components/header.html 11 additions, 0 deletions_includes/components/header.html
- _includes/components/mermaid.html 5 additions, 0 deletions_includes/components/mermaid.html
- _includes/components/search_footer.html 7 additions, 0 deletions_includes/components/search_footer.html
- _includes/components/search_header.html 9 additions, 0 deletions_includes/components/search_header.html
- _includes/components/sidebar.html 69 additions, 0 deletions_includes/components/sidebar.html
- _includes/icons/code_copy.html 1 addition, 1 deletion_includes/icons/code_copy.html
- _includes/icons/document.html 6 additions, 0 deletions_includes/icons/document.html
- _includes/icons/expand.html 6 additions, 0 deletions_includes/icons/expand.html
- _includes/icons/icons.html 13 additions, 0 deletions_includes/icons/icons.html
- _includes/icons/link.html 6 additions, 0 deletions_includes/icons/link.html
- _includes/icons/menu.html 6 additions, 0 deletions_includes/icons/menu.html
- _includes/icons/search.html 6 additions, 0 deletions_includes/icons/search.html
- _layouts/default.html 8 additions, 209 deletions_layouts/default.html
- _layouts/minimal.html 60 additions, 0 deletions_layouts/minimal.html
- assets/js/just-the-docs.js 3 additions, 1 deletionassets/js/just-the-docs.js
- docs/customization.md 155 additions, 0 deletionsdocs/customization.md
Loading
Please register or sign in to comment